Skip to main content
How to Use AI as a Manager
TMThomas McCleanยท Engineering Managerยท 7 min read
  • AI
  • Claude
  • Productivity
  • Leadership
  • Team management

How to Use AI as a Manager

AI can save managers hours each week. Practical use cases that actually work, from preparing 1:1s to drafting feedback and summarising your team data.

Most managers know AI tools exist. Some have tried them. Fewer use them consistently for actual management work, because the advice tends to be vague. "Use AI to be more productive" is not a workflow. The real barrier is not access - it is knowing which parts of your week are worth routing through an AI tool and which are not. Here is what genuinely helps.

The best use of AI in management is not writing for you. It is helping you arrive at every conversation better prepared and leave it with cleaner follow-through.

Preparing for meetings before you walk in

Preparation is where AI earns its keep for managers. The pattern is the same regardless of meeting type: give the AI the relevant context, ask a specific question, and use the output as a starting point - not a script.

Before a one-to-one, paste in your last two or three sets of notes and ask: what patterns do you notice, what topics keep coming up, what have we not discussed in a while? You will often surface something you had filed away mentally as resolved. Before a performance review, the same approach works across a whole year of notes. The AI does not tell you what to think - it pulls threads together so you arrive with a cleaner view. See 50 great one-to-one questions for what to do with that preparation once you are in the room.

Without AI prep

๐Ÿ“„ Scanning last 4 catchup docs
๐Ÿค” Cannot recall what we resolved
๐Ÿ” Searching email for context
โฐ 8 minutes to the meeting
๐Ÿ˜ฌ Going in blind again

Context is scattered. You react instead of lead.

With AI prep

๐Ÿ’ก 3 patterns identified
โ“ 4 suggested questions
๐ŸŽฏ 2 open actions flagged
๐Ÿ“Œ Topic not discussed in 6 weeks

Two minutes. Genuinely prepared.

The same principle applies to skip-levels, all-hands meetings, and team retrospectives. Give the AI the agenda and any relevant background, then ask it to surface the questions your team is most likely to have. You will not be caught off guard.

Writing tasks that eat the most time

Management involves a lot of writing that does not feel like writing: feedback, job descriptions, promotion cases, status updates, and follow-up emails after difficult conversations. None of it is glamorous, but all of it matters. AI shortens the distance between knowing what you want to say and saying it clearly.

Common writing tasks - and how to approach them

FeedbackDescribe the situation and behaviour. Ask AI to frame it constructively and specifically.Saves ~20 min
Job descriptionGive the role brief and must-haves. Ask for a draft. Refine once, not five times.Saves ~40 min
Promotion caseList the evidence. Ask AI to structure it against the levelling criteria.Saves ~60 min
Meeting summaryPaste your rough notes. Ask for a clean summary with actions and owners.Saves ~15 min

The key is to give the AI your raw material, not ask it to generate from nothing. "Write me feedback for someone who missed deadlines" produces something generic. "Here are my notes on the last three incidents - help me write feedback that is specific, fair, and forward-looking" produces something you can actually use.

The same logic applies to promotion cases. If you know someone deserves to be promoted but struggle to articulate why at the right level of detail, AI can help you turn a list of examples into a coherent narrative. You still need to own the evidence and the judgement. The AI helps with the structure and the framing.

How AI works inside Manager Toolkit

Manager Toolkit has AI built in rather than bolted on. AI summaries scan your catchup notes, actions, and survey results and surface what you actually need to know - without you having to prompt anything. You open the dashboard and the patterns are already there.

For more direct interaction, the MCP server lets you connect Manager Toolkit to Claude and query your team data in plain language. What actions have been open the longest? What themes keep coming up in catchups this quarter? Answered instantly, without leaving the tool you are already in. Connecting Manager Toolkit to Claude walks through the setup.

AI Summary - This Week

Powered by AI
๐Ÿ“Š

Patterns this month

Career growth mentioned in 4 of 6 catchups

โšก

Actions needing attention

3 overdue, 2 assigned to you

๐Ÿ’ฌ

Team sentiment

Positive overall, one flag on workload

๐Ÿ”

Recurring theme

Deployment process - 3rd consecutive retro

The difference between AI summaries inside a purpose-built tool and pasting notes into a generic chat interface is context. Manager Toolkit knows your team, your history, and the shape of your work. The summaries reflect that. You are not starting from scratch every time.

What AI cannot do for you

AI is worth using for the tasks above. It is not worth using as a substitute for the parts of management that require human judgement and genuine relationship. The distinction matters, because the line is easy to blur.

  • Reading the roomAI cannot tell you how someone felt when they said something. It cannot pick up on the hesitation before an answer, or the flatness in a voice that usually sounds engaged. You still need to be present and paying attention.
  • Making the callWhether someone is ready for promotion, whether a performance issue is a capability gap or a motivation issue, whether to extend trust or tighten oversight - those decisions are yours. AI can help you prepare, not decide.
  • The relationshipConsistency, follow-through, and genuine interest in someone's career cannot be outsourced. If your one-to-ones feel like they are going through the motions, AI-generated questions will not fix that.
  • AccountabilityIf you commit to something in a meeting, AI cannot follow through for you. The actions still need an owner, and that owner is often you. Use Manager Toolkit to track them so nothing disappears.

Used well, AI removes the friction from preparation and writing so you have more capacity for the things that only you can do. That is the trade worth making.

Frequently asked questions

AI built into your management toolkit

Summaries, patterns, and MCP access to your team data. Free to start.