It often starts with a quiet comment in a catchup. "I have been thinking about my options." Or maybe it is more direct: "I have been offered something else." However the conversation begins, the next few minutes matter more than you think. Your reaction sets the tone for everything that follows, whether that is a genuine attempt to keep them or a graceful transition out.
When someone tells you they are thinking about leaving, resist the urge to fix it immediately. Listen first. Understand what is actually driving the decision before you respond.
The Stay Conversation vs the Exit Conversation
There are two very different conversations here, and you need to figure out which one you are having quickly. The stay conversation happens when someone is unhappy but persuadable. They want something to change, whether that is their role, their growth opportunities, their compensation, or the work itself. They are telling you because they hope you will do something about it. The exit conversation happens when the decision is already made. They are not asking for change. They are telling you the outcome.
Stay conversation signals
There is still room to act.
Exit conversation signals
The decision is made. Shift to transition.
The most important thing you can do in either case is listen without getting defensive. If you react with guilt-tripping ("after everything we have done for you") or dismissiveness ("everyone goes through this, just give it time"), you will lose trust regardless of whether they stay or go. Being genuinely good at difficult conversations means staying calm when the news is uncomfortable.
When to Fight for Someone
Not every departure is worth fighting. That sounds harsh, but it is honest. If someone is leaving for reasons you genuinely cannot address, like a career change, a relocation, or an opportunity that is simply better than what you can offer, then fighting for them is selfish. You are asking them to stay for your convenience, not their benefit. The best managers know when to advocate and when to let go.
Fight for someone when the reason they want to leave is something you can fix. If it is lack of growth, explore what a stretch assignment or new responsibility might look like. If it is compensation, see what you can do. If it is feeling undervalued, that is a problem with your management, and it is worth addressing regardless of whether they stay. The foundation for these conversations is the trust you have built over time.
Should you counter?
Can you address the root cause?
Is the change sustainable long-term?
Are they still engaged in the work?
If you do make a counter-offer, make it genuine and specific. "I will try to get you more money" is not a counter-offer. "I have spoken to my manager and I can offer a 15% increase effective next month, plus a move to the platform team starting in Q3" is. Vague promises insult the intelligence of someone who has already taken the time to explore other options.
When to Let Go Gracefully
Letting someone go gracefully is one of the most underrated skills in management. When the decision is final, your job shifts from retention to transition. This is not about you. It is about making the departure as smooth as possible for the person, the team, and the work.
- Respect the decisionDo not sulk, guilt-trip, or make them feel bad. Thank them for telling you. Express genuine appreciation for their contribution. How you respond in this moment will define how they remember working for you.
- Control the narrativeAgree together on how and when to tell the team. Do not let it leak through rumour. A clear, positive announcement respects both the person leaving and the people staying.
- Protect the relationshipPeople remember how they were treated on the way out. A good exit creates an ambassador for your team and your organisation. A bad one creates a cautionary tale that future candidates will hear about.
- Learn from itNot every departure is a failure, but every departure is feedback. What could you have done differently? What systemic issues contributed? Use this as data to improve retention for the rest of the team.
Having a solid offboarding process makes the practical side of this much easier. When you know exactly what needs to happen, you can focus your energy on the human side rather than scrambling to figure out knowledge transfer and access removal at the last minute.
Planning the Transition
Once the decision is confirmed, shift to planning. A messy handover hurts the team and the departing person. A well-planned transition protects the work and shows respect for everyone involved. Use Catchups to structure the remaining conversations and track what needs to be handed over before their last day.
Transition plan
The transition period is also when you should be thinking about the rest of the team. They will have questions and concerns. Be open about what is happening, be clear about what changes for them, and be honest if you do not have all the answers yet. A departure handled well can actually strengthen team trust. It shows that you manage people as individuals, even when they are on their way out.
Frequently asked questions
Stay close to your team
Use Catchups to have better conversations and spot problems early. Free to start.